He let the Inspector have them check. There is no evidence of corrupt motive on Kell's part.
Change &.
All the improper conversation alleged had passed though an interpreter who cannot be found at the trial.
I disagree and the evidence have been tampered with. Sir.
The witness was led by leading questions, and the answers were put into the witness's mouth. If you read the answers without the questions, they consist of "It's yes" "I did".
Mr. Jacombe Smith ought to have known better. I regard this charge as not proved.
In my opinion, a light punishment may be awarded for the goods unpaid for - viz. we make him pay for all the goods he received & reprimand him. Or we do nothing.
I am sorry to differ from Sir C. Fiddes. There is much complaint, no doubt, the Chinese are unwilling witnesses, but we must not do what is improper from a judicial point of view because of the difficulty of proof.
HBC 28/1
Sir J. Hayford 7
Mr. Churchill
I do not add to the minutes the case has been thoroughly examined. CP.d 29
A Case of Generally which justifies suspicion.
We are wanting in Appeal obliged to.
Conduct must have proofs.
In the case of Jeumo DALK, advantage of seeing.
Acting badly.
Land was Cabossed.
Cat Cam Lim properly tells.
Complaining in a casual way.
As far as I would radio Kin.
Witnesses have to bring heaps.
I do not propose to work on the fashions.
As applying cursorily to Cases of the kind. I gather from the pattern with training dissemination & to Fiddes' minute, and I therefore feel a natural reluctance to attach a severe criticism.
Page 303
Page 304
He let the Inspector have them cheak. There is no evidence of corrupt motive
ན
Kell's part.
Change &.
All the improper conversation alleged
hased though.
an interpreter who cannot be found at the tual.
I dissey and the evidence
Have Tim. Sver
a
the witnen
д
question
Coring
leading question rever answer was put into the witnesses in with. If you read the answers without the questions you they consist of "Its "yes" "I did"
Ø
Zur Sacombe Smith ought to have known better. I regard this change as not proved.
In my opinion
O
light
punishment my be awarded for the hams unpaid for- viz
Iwe make him pay for all
the foord he reca
& refrimend
him. Dwe do nothing
very sorry
to differ from
I am chu Fiddes. There is much complai
unwilling
no doubt, the Chinese are witnesses, but we must not do
what is improfer from a judicial. point of view because your diffic HBC 28/1
of proof
Sir J. Hofword 7
M- Churchill
I do not add to the minutes the case
har bom la
thoroughly
examined CP.d 29
A Case of Generaller
which justifies despicion
We
ŵ
wh
A
agases
A
Charger
is
wanting
t
un
Appeal oblid
L
303
loors
Conduct
Hut that
must have ferofs
betha
In th
Jeumo
DALK
advantage of seeing
لمسية
Acting
bad
4
Land
la Cabossed бытты
£
A
with us
Cat Cam Lim
properly tells
willen
Comed
لما
fisk
Widence thickly
farmer de
in
A cuscal way
bus I would
radio Kin
1
Wytwines
have t
brides
heaps
A
far as
hv.
despatch
ختاه
I do not propna
m
علقا شما
oke
working
fashores
น IG
Renom
30.1.
مہنگی
As applying cursally I Cares of the sund. Igapattern
{
with trening disewation & to Fidder necuate. and I therefor fuel a natural reluctare 2 axtarch a
ku animates
Widula
%
¿
an Excenter Conmich
ů
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.